Brogan's Point police detective Sam Harper needs to find out who's sending Cali Bowen threatening emails. Cali grew up on a commune and now she teaches yoga, hoping to bring balance and inner peace to her students. Sam is a New York City transplant, cynical and tough. She's stir-fried tofu; he's red meat and French fries. But her idealism touches him, and he's determined to nail the creep who's harassing her. Sam wants to save Cali, but Cali believes Sam is the one who needs saving. She senses a dark wound inside him, a deep sorrow. She knows she could bring balance and serenity into his life, if only he'd open his mind and his heart.

Sam and Cali both need rescuing. When the Magic Jukebox plays Rescue Me for them, the song's magical power gathers them within its spell.