They've mastered the art of avoiding each other. But this Christmas, a fire, a twelve-year-old matchmaker, and a whole lot of grace might just light the way back to love. Sue Smith is the heart of Laurel Ridge-owner of Sue's Pizza, choir director, event organizer, and the kind of woman who always shows up with a smile and a helping hand. But behind her cheerful demeanor is a quiet ache. Divorced for six years, Sue has poured herself into work, church, and community, keeping the loneliness at bay. Until a fire nearly destroys her beloved restaurant-and the man who broke her heart shows up to save it. Steve Johnson has spent his life saving others. As Laurel Ridge's fire chief, he's earned the town's trust-but lost his wife and precious time with his daughter in the process.

Now, with their twelve-year-old daughter Emma growing up and asking deeper questions, Steve can't ignore the regrets. He wants a second chance with the woman he never stopped loving. But after all the hurt, is Sue ready to let him back in? With Christmas around the corner, Steve offers to help Sue rebuild the pizzeria-and maybe a few broken bridges along the way. Late nights sanding drywall and untangling twinkle lights turn into honest conversations, laughter, and glimpses of the love they once shared. Meanwhile, Emma plays her part as chief holiday matchmaker, roping her parents into caroling, tree decorating, and one "accidental" family movie night after another. But old wounds don't heal overnight, and Sue's protective father isn't convinced Steve deserves another shot. As they spend more time together, healing begins to take root under the warmth of Christmas lights and second chances. But rebuilding a relationship means facing the past head-on-and trusting that grace can redeem even the most broken stories.