Elementary school music teacher Callie Stevens thinks she's finally figured out God's plan for her life--she even made a list to keep her on track. Moving in with her brother and reconnecting with her ex-boyfriend are at the top of the list. What's not on the list is running into her childhood crush, Ryan. God wanted her to connect with Kyle, right? Trying to figure out God's plan is hard enough. But a dating-averse older brother, the young blonde who adores him, a pregnant best friend, and Callie's continual mishaps make her wonder whether her best laid plans were truly God-inspired.