A comprehensive, insightful, and robust biography of a transcendent but neglected figure. (The New York Times) Loughery deftly narrates a life spent in defense of immigrants and as an imperfect advocate for tolerance and, yes, diversity. (Wall Street Journal) A timely insight into the man who founded St. Patrick's cathedral, providing a fascinating glimpse of the world of Irish America in the 19th century. (The Irish Times) Loughery's work deftly portrays a key period in US history and the role of one of the figures who helped to define that era. (Library Journal) In this superb biography by Loughery, Hughes takes his place among the movers and shakers of nineteenth century New York City. (The Bowery Boys) Excellent. (Catholic New York) Loughery has convincingly painted a portrait of both Catholic New York as well as the larger American culture of the mid-nineteenth century, while also weaving into his tapestry the strengths and weaknesses, triumphs and failures, of the prelate who led the archdiocese for over two decades.

Dagger John is a considerable contribution to United States Catholic history, the role of the Irish in it, and the character of one who never shied from controversy. (Catholic Historical Review) [A] magnificent biographical study of Hughes, one that plumbs the depths of his character, situates his own ethnic self-identity, and skillfully fits him into the lives of his contemporaries. A fair and even-handed presentation of an important ecclesiastic of the nineteenth-century church, a man who served his adopted land well and to the end. (The Journal of Religion) This full, informative, and sympathetic treatment is written in an accessible style and will be required reading for anyone interested in the contribution of the Irish to 19th-century America. (Choice) Loughery has written an engaging contribution to the field of Irish American history that wears its erudition lightly and ought to be appreciated by scholars and general readers alike (Journal of American History).