"When Miss Stillford, Quinnie's beloved teacher, fails to show up for their first day of school, Quinnie is convinced that her teacher has been kidnapped. Quinnie's mom, the sheriff of the small town, does not share her daughter's concern and tells Quinnie that Miss Stillford probably went on vacation. Quinnie, along with two friends, embarks on an investigation of her own. No one is safe from suspicion--Miss Stillford's former boyfriend, a mysterious man, even the sisters who live in the dilapidated convent. Also concerning is a row of abandoned houses. Since Quinnie's mom is also the town's realtor and head of the postal department, Quinnie has access to supplies like keys, as well as evidence-gathering skills and determination. In Surrisi's debut novel, she has created a strong and unique setting in the small waterfront town of Maiden Rock, Maine. A map may help readers visualize the places Quinnie visits as she finds and follows clues.

Although there are moments of seemingly forced coincidence, such as Quinnie losing her phone at critical moments, young readers will probably be able to look past that flaw. The Maypop Kidnapping is a sweet mystery that manages to have suspense, bad guys, and danger but avoids gore and being too scary. This new sleuth also finds herself juggling other classic tween issues, such as friendships, struggles with parents, and making decisions. Quinnie stays true to her instincts, and the plot offers a happily resolved ending. This book is recommended for upper elementary mystery collections."--VOYA.