"[This] account sheds considerable light on a dimly illuminated period of Jewish-American music, which now emerges in its full richness and complexity."--Mark Slobin, author of Chosen Voices: The Story of the American Cantorate "Occasionally an historical work provides the breadth and details of an era that forever changes our perceptions of that period. Judah Cohen's book accomplishes this feat for Jewish music in America in the nineteenth century."-- AJL Reviews "The story Cohen tells by analyzing these musical works, their authors, underlying ideas, and envisaged practices is fascinating and thoroughly researched. Cohen succeeds in his aim of "chronicling this era in musical terms" without requiring in-depth specialist music knowledge of the reader (p. 9). The author does not trail off in detailed musical analyses of individual compositions. Rather, he examines music publications as a whole, in designing a bigger picture of their genesis and history.

He analyzes their scopes and paratexts, their authorship, their meaning for the performance and the liturgy, and their reception in Jewish communities. The generous use of illustrations, showing the original musical material rather than rewritten musical examples, gives an unaltered impression of the settings, layout, and presentation of the original works. A large number of quotations from primary sources, like the contemporary press and meeting minutes from community organizations, make this pioneering study a vivid reading. Unmuting the American Jewish nineteenth century, it is indeed an important contribution to American Jewish history and Jewish music studies."--Martha Stellmacher, Europäisches Zentrum für Jüdische Musik, H-Judaic "Cohen's achievement here sets a high standard for historical musicology, engaging the archival record while contributing to the establishment of evidence-based criteria for identifying the "Jewish" in "Jewish Religious Music"--criteria that actively deconstruct inherited wisdom that has inhibited the scope of research agendas."--Jeremiah Lockwood, Musica Judaica "Judah M. Cohen's work takes a refreshing approach to Jewish music history, which to date has been largely examined within its own context--that is, away from discussions of other sacred (or secular) music. Cohen's work is an important addition to both Jewish music and more mainstream musicological literature.

"--Danielle Padley, University of Cambridge, Notes.