"An important new contribution to understanding the problem of evil, especially given its attention to the Thomistic approach to the subject, which has been influential historically but too often neglected in contemporary discussion." --Edward Feser, professor of philosophy, Pasadena City College "The idea of a good and loving God is clearly on the ropes in this book. Can he survive the beating? This dramatic bout between Huffling and Whittenberger--with Shermer, Sterba, and Howe as astute referees--will keep you on the edge of your seat." --Dan Barker, author of Mere Morality.